I swear this is not going to be a week of holiday-themed polybags. Today’s set, 30584 Winter Holiday Train, and yesterday’s set just happened to be a holiday-themed coincidence.

Just based on the name, I thought maybe this was a mini version of the old Winter Holiday Train creator set, 10254 Winter Holiday Train. Unfortunately, they only share a name in common. Whatever made 10254 great is not present here.

It’s got weird proportions. The engine is wide and squat, with a narrow wheel base.

The presents in the second car are HUGE.

The caboose is not caboose colored. I tend to think of them as being red. Had the designer swapped the colors between the engine and the caboose, it would have been closer to 10254 boosting this set a couple of points.

I get that it’s supposed to be holiday themed, so the colors are what they are, but it’s not really working for me.

I will say this set would sit nicely on a sill or on a bookcase during the holidays. It may look weird, but the small wheels make it look cartoonish. I guess when it comes to Christmas, I find myself a little more lenient on the scoring. In our house, when the holidays roll around, we break open our storage bins with all our Christmas sets and spread them around the house. So I tend to look at sets like this to see if it’s something that I’d look forward to pulling out of storage to put up somewhere. And I’d have to say yes to that. But yesterday’s Santa set can still go straight to the trash bin.

Does It Suck or Does It Rock?


30584 Winter Holiday Train isn’t great but it’s grown on me. It’s got the charm of an ugly dog.


There’s no sponsor this week, and with sponsorships lasting a whole week, you can get plenty of exposure for mere pennies. Pennies I say! Want to sponsor a review? Send me a message to admin@fbtb.net or hit me up on discord of the polybag set you have that you want me to review. If selected, in exchange for the set you’ll get a mention right here in the review post and a link to your website or social media account or just about anything else.. Nearly free advertising, so what’s stopping you?

You Can Win This And Every Other Polybag I Review This Year

I’ll be raffling every polybag I review this year in one big lot, all 260 sets (with the possibility of more). Each set will be individually stored in a ziploc baggie complete with the extra pieces, instructions, and the actual polybag bag it came in. The cost of a raffle ticket is just $1 USD and you can enter as many times as you want. Send a PayPal payment to paypal@fbtb.net for $1 USD for every ticket you want to purchase. DO NOT send one payment for multiple entries i.e. do not send one $5 USD payment for five tickets; five $1 USD payments must be made instead. Raffle is open to everyone in the world except where raffles are illegal. Be sure to put “POLYBAG RAFFLE” in the notes section of the payment in order to be entered successfully. Winner will be drawn sometime sometime in the second half of 2023 and contacted at the PayPal email address the payment was sent from to arrange for delivery. For a running list of all the sets that you can win, check this Google spreadsheet.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.