Life can be a funny thing, sometimes. I started writing this review December 18th, 2015, after I’d slept through a midnight showing of Force Awakens in IMAX. Then I got this crazy idea that everyone on the staff should go write their own impressions of it… before I realized there are like two of us (or four, depending on what’s going on), and we have jobs and kids and lives. So it just sort of fell by the wayside as we went about reviewing other things.

My initial thoughts were captured in our forum thread on it, as well as tucked away in the reviews for a lot of the Force Awakens sets. Since after watching this movie, one of the first things I did was run out and buy the new Falcon and Kylo Ren’s shuttle… it stands that I really liked the movie. I’m under no pretension that this was the greatest Star Wars movie of all time (obviously, that’s Jedi, given my love of Ewoks). At the same time, it seems pretty popular to throw shade at this particular movie… be it because of the (intentional) similarities between it and A New Hope, the involvement of Disney, or for the people that stopped enjoying anything Star Wars made after 1983.

When I was writing reviews for the original and prequel trilogies back before this came out, starting with Episode I and working up to the good ones, I was all prepared for the time when I got to The Force Awakens review and had to rip into it. The odds of it working were stacked against it for a whole variety of reasons. It was Disney, who’s focus is always going to be on generating merchandise over storytelling (not that they don’t tell a story). It was Star Wars, where half of the existing films are considerably worse than the rest. It was JJ Abrams, who has already ruined a lot of Star Trek for fans. There had also been some pretty heavy-handed actions by Disney and Co. leading up to it, issuing takedowns and threats, etc.

The hype around this film was absolutely unreal. It was pretty unlikely that it could ever come within the same zip code on delivering on that hype. Star Wars fans are just the worst, and nothing ever, EVER If it was awful, we all would have sat back and gone “see, told you it was going to be terrible!” There’s a problem with that whole narrative, though…

… is that it was actually a pretty good movie.

I’m not going to bother with spoiler warnings… if you haven’t seen this in the past two years, you’re not going to. This review isn’t for you, and you’re probably already ranting about it in the comments based on what I put above about it being “pretty good.” At least one of our forum members, who I believe hates everything, uses every opportunity he can to complain about all things Star Wars since 1980, and Disney in particular.

I take a certain amount of humor in this idea that Disney has somehow been whoring out Star Wars since they got their hands on it, as if that wasn’t the only reason that Lucas even made Star Wars movies. I mean, the single smartest thing he ever did was secure the merchandising rights for the films before he set off to make them. Sure, the films themselves have made several boat loads of money, but they don’t hold a candle to what the rest of this stuff.

I own a set of these. They are hanging up in my office window right now, as they do every Christmas.

I mean, the whole reason this site exists is because Lucasfilm was willing to license it to what was a relatively minor toy manufacturer at the time (everyone had heard of them, sure, but they held nothing compared to the big ones they have since choked out like a Hutt).

There’s something amazing about going to the theater and watching a Star Wars movie, even though when Force Awakens came out it was a 50/50 chance you were going to see a good movie when you did it. I still remember what it was like to go to it, the first new Star Wars film in 11 years at the time. I went with a good friend of mine whom I see most movies with, and I’d secured the tickets for the first IMAX 3D showing after the meltdown that was purchasing tickets for TFA.

The seats weren’t the best, but they weren’t awful. We were positioned at the center of the theater at pretty much the exact point where your field of view took in the entire screen edge-to-edge. That may sound cool, but it also means that you sit entirely locked in place for the entire film when you take it all in.

Much like how the ultimate judgement of a LEGO set is past the part count, the accuracy, or the figure selection and really just the reaction to holding the complete set in your hands that first time… how I feel about TFA is influenced greatly by the fact that I sat there for the 2+ hours of the movie latched to the screen. My back was killing me after the film, but it was worth it entirely.

Less ridiculous than 94% of what happened in the Extended Universe

That’s not to say it’s a perfect film by any means. In fact, it really missteps almost right out of the gate with the addition of Lor San “Who the Hell is This?” Tekka. I get, from a film perspective, where they were trying to go here, but it feels like a huge missed opportunity to use a new character who is basically a redshirt to introduce us to two new characters.

One of the best ideas I heard after this movie came out was that this character should have been someone from the prequels or original trilogy. If I have anything that worries me about Abrams coming back for Episode IX, it’s that he has been open about hating the prequels and didn’t use them for anything of note in this movie. I mean, there was a mention of a Clone Army but that was about it.

You know who he should have used? Jar Jar Binks. I know others have have suggested something similar, or Lando, or who knows who else. But Jar Jar could have been “toned” down from his awfulness of Episode I to something more like Episode III, or maybe even something more muted. Make it so he had spent his entire life since the events of Revenge of the Sith trying to make amends.

And then he gets cut down for his actions… You get to advance the story and give some pretty huge fan service along the way.

Be honest… you’ve imagined yourself doing precisely this very thing on more than one occasion

The shaky start is fixed very quickly after we get our introductions to the new cast that will be leading Star Wars going forward. More than that, a tone is set at the start that is very different from what we saw in either the original or prequel trilogy when we see the First Order show up.

Has anyone ever thought about how the First Order has basically pinned their hopes on the goofy boyfriend from Girls, Bill Weasley, and the best warrior in Westros? Only one of those seems like a good idea…

For one… they are legitimately intimidating. We see them mow down that village at the start, and actually hit things. Sure, their tactics are far more about intimidation than survival, because that was a rather ridiculous strategy in landing over the hill and walking in.

More than that, we see it happen more than once, because later when Poe and Finn, and Finn and Rey’s escape from Jakku. TIE fighters can hit things, Stormtroopers are only missing because they’re trying to capture them alive.

The slaughter of innocents got him to defect, but he’s totally chill about killing dozens of his former comrades.

Speaking of the First Order, a common knock on the ship design and selection in the movie. Everything we see, for the most part, is derivative of something that was in the Original Trilogy. In truth, for me, that makes far more sense than the fact that we saw new ships and designs between each of the prequels. I always draw a common parallel to how military technology works in the real world. New stuff gets introduced, sure, but things stay in service for decades or longer, it gets refined and improved upon. The TIE Fighters and X-Wings were proven platforms so it makes sense they would continue to use and improve them.

I expected to hate this droid… yet I love him so much

The new cast, though, is what makes this movie, ultimately. There is a much different tone set when Poe is captured by the first order, with jokes being through around. It’s a humor that I love, despite my total lack of sarcasm in anything I write, and it’s also a clear note that what we are going to see from this movie in writing and dialog is unlike anything the previous movies gave us. The one-liners are gone, thankfully, and we have something that people would actually say in their place.

The movie, most certainly (purposefully) borrows plot beats from A New Hope, but it is a vast oversimplification to call it a ripoff of Episode IV. Even the basic tone, where A New Hope is just that, the hope that Skywalker brings, the Force Awakens is far more about the loss of it. It’s a story about failure, on multiple fronts. Luke’s failure building the new Jedi, Leia’s failure to make the Republic understand the threat the first order poses, and Han’s failure to his son. It’s those failures that drive the entire movie, where in A New Hope what drove them was more or less “the good fight.”

You know, this is basically R.E.D. 3

Episode IV was a rather simple hero’s journey. It’s far more complex here… we get to follow it for Rey and Finn, both, and in far different ways. With Rey, we see her get a mentor in Han… and I think I would have been very cool with watching the whole series go to just the galactic journeys of Han, Chewie, and Rey. In the end, we don’t get to see her make the choice until just before the credits roll.

With Finn, it was him running away in terror and fear, one that he really didn’t overcome until the very end. It’s these sorts of things that make the real difference in making Force Awakens a distinct film in its own right. The major beats line up, but what’s in between is very different. We’re not looking at Vanilla Ice type nonsense here…

What I would give for this to be turned into a video game… I miss when Star Wars games weren’t just festering garbage

That being said, one of the big problems in the movie is caused by the fact that they put so much into this movie. A New Hope had a benefit in that there was no background needed for it at all… it was all brand new. Much like how the prequels had to deal with the fact that we always knew what was going to happen, this movie has the extra burden of we knew what happened before and it had to try and there are a lot of blanks to fill in on what happened between the celebrations we saw in Jedi and the fact that the war is seemingly still on.

You have to buy the Visual Dictionary to have any idea who this character is and why you should care about her dying

Those blanks mean that there is a lot of character development time is linked directly to painting the last twenty years, and there was never going to be enough time for it. Disney tries to address this, to a point, with the new (and better) way that canon is handled now. Blanks are filled in with the books, the comics, and other materials.

To think that this was the most high-profile cameo in the whole movie

So… let’s talk about the common argument about Rey being a Mary Sue, and the complaint about her fight at the end of the movie with Kylo Ren (who had taken a pretty serious injury from Chewie before hand). The idea that she could stand toe-to-toe with Kylo, or fly the Falcon, or do any of the other stuff we see, isn’t honestly all that different than what we saw with Anakin in Episode I (or III and the Dark Side) or Luke in A New Hope and Empire.

The force awakens and gives someone far more ability than they would normally have. I mean, even the music keys in for it, because the same theme played here  that we saw in the previous films when it happens. Even in that final fight, Ren was basically toying with her for the majority of the fight, clearly the superior fighter, in a very similar fashion to what we saw with Luke and Vader. It wasn’t until the moment she embraced the force she was able to bring it up to any sort of parity, and that whole thing was short lived before the whole planet kerploded.

Ultimately, there’s far more we don’t know about the character, by design. We saw the force using her, much like we had before. We saw her using the skills she needed to survive on Jakku, and the hints that there quite clearly is a lot she does not remember about herself. The whole flashback turns the fact that we don’t have time to fill into the blanks for her as something intrinsic to the character.

Unlike pretty much anyone else in the previous Star Wars movies, we have no idea who Rey is or if there is an explanation. We get clues, sure, but they could all be red herrings or just conjecture… “That lightsaber was Luke’s, and his father’s before him, and now, it calls to you” is what Maz says to Rey after the vision, and it could be they already told us who she is. At the same time, no one that should recognize who she is does. If Rey was a Skywalker I have to assume one of the main cast would have reacted in some way.

You could fire the Starkiller weapon through this plot-hold and end up missing. Addressed, kind of, in the comics, but not at all in a satisfying way.

The biggest weakness to the movie, and where the knockoff Episode IV critique really does have some validity, is in the whole Starkiller base. Han even makes the point “so it’s bigger, so what” when they are talking about it, but it turns out that the Imperial types have really committed to this whole “weapons of ridiculous destruction” thing.

The weapon itself is stupid, and the very concept has far too many problems. The Death Star was somewhat silly, but at least you could wrap your head around the idea of “really powerful laser.” How does the base even work? It was firing at multiple systems that were “far away” according to Hux, and we saw it across star systems presumably thousands of light years apart. Sure, visually it looks cool, but spend any time thinking about it and it is just stupid.

These guys could make a great fusion of buddy cop / romantic comedy

It feels like there could have been a better way to go about this very sudden escalation in hostilities between the First Order and the Resistance (given that the Republic is basically wiped out). The whole thing feels without stakes, and that hurts the end of this film. Sure, the X-Wing pilots are dying, the we know the good guys are going to blow it up at this point because that’s what’s happened in nearly half of all Star Wars films at this point.

What the Starkiller Base does set up is for us to have the moment we all expected to come, yet that foreknowledge in no way softens the blow, in the confrontation between Han Solo and his son. Anyone who knows a bit about Harrison Ford knows he’s wanted that character dead since Empire. Though he says he didn’t ask for him to be killed off, I have to think it was key to making it actually happen.

Here’s what I would have done to try and fix this problem, and at the same time, fill in some of the backstory. Skip the earlier destruction of the Republic system, and give us the scene we needed where Leia is trying to make her case that the First Order should be opposed. That’s actually what happened, if you read some of the books or comics… Leia was more or less forced out and the Republic wanted a diplomatic agreement with the First Order and ignored the threat.

In my own personal head canon, I imagine that this is the image that Don falls asleep to every night.

Then, make the battle go down in a similar way. Han, Finn, and Chewie go to rescue Rey / sabotage the base, the X-Wings show up to try and destroy it, etc. And have them succeed… but not before it fires the shot that will blow up the Republic system. Have the resistance succeed in blowing up the weapon, but failing in preventing it from being used. Plus, you get the benefit of following a closer parallel to the slow burn sudden explosion that we saw with Ben and Han.

The first Jedi Temple was in Ireland. Galen Tyrol settled in Scotland at the end of BSG… I wonder if the Jedi and Cylons ever went to war?

The whole movie itself, is pinned to trying to answer one question… “where is Luke Skywalker.” Likely that is the same question that all of us had watching the movie and waiting for him to show up. He was there in the flashback, and in the last minute, having never said a word. I mean, there were extras with more stuff to do on the film.

For me, at least, what it managed to do was get me excited about Star Wars and wanting to see more… something that the prequels never did. Sure, I went and watched them, but it never had the draw that the original movies did for me. This movie felt like it had a spark of that back, something that could certainly be built up into something greater.

We got new characters that all had far more charisma and presence than we got in the three movies that were released before it. The Prequels weren’t entirely bad, but they had the incredible ability to make great actors look mediocre and drain the chemistry out of anything. With this, we saw legitimate chemistry between actors and characters, and it made you want to see more of them. Even BB-8, who really looked like a just a shameless marketing stunt before the release, had a personality that simply shined.

This movie also represented the introduction of a new “line” within Star Wars sets. It used to be we got OT and PT sets, with the occasional EU set. When Clone Wars came along, it replaced most of the PT stuff, and when Rebels showed up, it displaced a lot of the OT. Here, though, we just got a mixture of all three. The initial sets were somewhat lackluster. The First Order TIE and Poe’s Halloween X-Wing were standouts, but Kylo Ren’s shuttle was junk and most of the rest were somewhat forgettable.

Curiously, two years later, nearly all of those sets are still on the market, as well as some follow-up sets. Unfortunately, while Force Awakens was visually stunning, it just did not lend itself to a great number of remarkable sets. Instead, we had a color reskin within a few months of the first wave. The first big set was the UCS Millennium Falcon, which would be generous to call a cluster at this point in how its been handled (not to mention the crazy price)… and it had to share it with the OT. We’ve received our first wave of Last Jedi sets already, and while I haven’t picked them up, the couple we’ve reviewed were not impressive. I hope that the movie is hiding better secrets that will show up in the future to wow us, but it seems like there is a big disconnect between the quality of the films and the quality of what we get for them.

When I was reviewing the OT and PT leading up to the release of Force Awakens, I had a bit of trouble trying to put numbers on some of the movies. I mean, the prequels are bad, but they are still Star Wars. I wonder about the people who say they love Star Wars, yet hate the prequels, the Disney stuff, and anything other than the first three (sometimes two) movies. Disney has actually done a great job producing content… Rebels is a great cartoon that has gone to far darker places than even the movies have wanted to tread.

The Force Awakens is a better Star Wars movie than any of the Prequels were… it’s also a better movie, quality wise, than any of them. It’s probably the most quality product of any Star Wars film before it… the original trilogy included, when it comes to visuals, dialog, direction, etc. That doesn’t mean it’s better than the original three films… it’s not. There was something magical in them that could not be recreated so easily, if at all, but that isn’t a bad thing. For me, I put this one just below Jedi on the list.

I’d still rank this one a four out of five in our completely arbitrary scale, though. I hadn’t watched it since sometime last year, and was surprised that it was just as fun to watch as the last time, and how there were still little things to notice in it.