Travel the dunes with the LEGO� Star Wars™ Ultimate Collector Series Sancrawler™

FBTB - From Bricks To Bothans

Follow us: RSS
News? Questions? Comments? Email!

Review: 75016 Homing Spider Droid

The official Lego set review forum. Please read the Guidelines before posting!

Review: 75016 Homing Spider Droid

Postby Staff » Fri Oct 25, 2013 6:11 am

Full Set

My love of walkers does have its limits, and the Spider Droid is one of those things I just never really understood. I mean, this is a universe where things can hover, jet into space, and use magic. I get why Republic and Empire used walkers, it was a mixture of intimidation and needing to move people from point-A to point-B. Droids don't have that problem... this guy is basically an elevated target that has limited movement and a firing arc. Like the rest of the Episode II sets we got in this wave (well, except the Geonosis Duel), this set is a revised Clone Wars set. The AT-TE and RGS had a very high bar to live up to (and went 50/50 on that front), the Tank Droid was for a forgettable set, and the Spider Droid has one of the lowest bars imaginable. The original spider droid was fragile, ugly, and overpriced (compounded by being a TRU exclusive if I remember right).

This version keeps the same price ($30), loses the exclusive tag, actually increases the piece count, and adds a new Jedi to the ever expanding palette of victims of poor decision making. That's not saying it's all roses in the improvement category, but at least things look a bit more promising on the "I don't feel like I'm being robbed" front.



Minifigures

We get four minifigs in this set, if you discount the little droid: a couple of Super Battle Droids, Stass Allie (which sounds like the punchline to "what sound does a Jedi make when he goes over a cliff... Alliiiiiiiiiiiiiieeeeeeeeeeee - Jango Fett"), and a generic Clone trooper. That's not a bad little mix.

Super Battle Droids

Super Battle Droids are a bit harder to get than regular battle droids (only currently available in the RGS or clearance 2012 Advent Calendars). These guys haven't really changed all that much since they were first introduced in the inaugural battle packs. The only variation has been adding a blaster arm (you know, something that would actually make sense in a war machine). I like the general idea of the SBDs, but I still don't like that hollow back. It seems like something that's overdue to be fixed.

Stass Allie

I'm pretty sure that we've gotten about eight hundred new Jedis this year in minifigure form (it may also be like ten, I'm fuzzy on numbers), and  this is just another one to add to the mix for our Episode II fun. I know nothing about this character, though it somehow hits into odd territory for LEGO, in that we have a female minifig, strange on its own. But one that appears to not be lily-white is also very cool.

Stass Allie - Back

 

I'm thinking that head could be turned into a pretty serviceable Storm minifig for us comic fans, even if the eyes are purple instead of white. The hair is odd, there is no alt face, and the printing on the tunic matches. She's a minor character, but I'm glad to have her to help diversify the Jedi palette.

 Clone Trooper Clone Trooper - Back


Our Clone buddy is a regular old clone, and that's a good thing. A lot of sets need more of him, and I always need more clones. Turns out, there were a lot of them.

Clone Trooper - Face

Regular generic face, no alt-face, and can be used almost anywhere. There's a lot to like with the newer clone variety. The only thing to be unhappy with is that you can't get more than one in any set.

Dwarf Spider Droid

There are actually two Spider Droids in this set, the big guy and the annoying little thing that's been a toss-in with a few different sets. I think this is the third version, but I'm way too lazy to go look it up (I seem to remember getting him once in blue and once in brown). I like little brick-built droids, typically, and there's he's simple but kind of nifty. I always like to see those little turret ball socket parts (and don't feel like parting out an AT-TE to a whole mess of them).

Dwarf Spider Droid - Front

These guys make far more sense to me than Battle Droids and Super Battle Droids in general (as does the Spider and Tank Droid). I mean, if you're going to build a robot army, what's the logic in making them less efficient at doing their job by making them look human. A Battle Droid can't do anything by itself... you have to give it a gun to actually be dangerous. I mean, look at it's hands and arms, they're not even articulated enough to be able to choke the enemy. Their best bet when sent out without a gun is to try to use overwhelming numbers so that when they're shot down they'll be able to crush an opponent or two to death.

Dwarf Spider Droid - Bottom

This guy, on the other hand, is basically a walking little turret. Sure, maybe he'd be a bit more efficient with a repulsorlift or some wheels, but he doesn't have to worry about visiting the armory before going out on the field. Even Skynet eventually knew that you wiped out humanity with giant robot space ships, not the fleshy little human analogs that they kept sending into battle.

Homing Spider Droid

The centerpiece of the set is the "Homing Spider Droid" that its named after. Of course, those keeping count at home will notice that it's about four legs short of being a spider (two if you're feeling generous and let it count the guns). Sure, it's probably just named for what it looks like, and maybe spiders in a galaxy far, far away only have four legs (thought it's fairly unlikely they'd be called "spiders" unless the universe just isn't very creative), but still...

The pictures really don't convey the biggest problem with this set: it's... awkward. It's not flimsy or fragile, but it doesn't sit all that well. It slides around on those feet badly, and the center ball tends to tip to one side or the other, causing one set of legs to bend in and the others to bend out. It probably took me two minutes to get this thing balanced just right when taking the picture, since just looking at it funny made it go off-center.

Homing Spider Droid - Legs and Center

The biggest problem with the old one wasn't the legs (though they were pretty bad as well), it was the center ball. The legs stuck into a technic brick on either side, and that made it somewhat wonky to pick up. The structure didn't tend to hold up, and it was easy to accidentally "crush" the ball and send it flying apart. I don't really rate a walker on how swooshable it is (what would be a good term, stompable?), but that hurt the set almost as bad as the price.

This design fixes that problem by using a large wheel as a center hub which connects the legs mechanism. Instead of a single pin, it's now a double technic pin, and it makes the structure very sturdy, even if the legs themselves are wobbly. So, very stompable, not very disaplayable.

Homing Spider Droid - Parts

The center ball actually splits into three distinct parts that thread through that center ring. The inclusion of the rounded big corner slopes, introduced back with the Prince of Persia line (and a couple of years after the last Spider Droid came out) make a world of difference over the blocky slopes. While the whole droid on big legs thing is kind of silly, this build just looks great. It's not even a contest for the look of this compared to the others, and this set marks a cheap way to stock up on those parts. Likewise, the little guns included on the top and bottom are quite improved, and I really like the general design of them. You could easily slap these parts as-is on to a capital or smuggler ship and they wouldn't look out-of-place at all.

Homing Spider Droid - Leg Detail

The last improvement in the set was adding some details to the leg. The old one was basically just a technic axle that looked awful when you put the thing together. Here, there are some tubes and a hub the hide that aspect and make it look like a leg instead of "we didn't want to put enough parts in this set." The real shame is that the leg doesn't keeps steady. How you see it above is the natural state it likes to go in, like it's ready to tip over.

It's a weird set in the grand scheme of things. It's obviously a big counterpoint to the big Episode II sets that favor the Republic (anyone want to bet we get an updated Hailfire droid next year), but it's still kind of obscure. We get droids and a clone, along with a new jedi, so the minifigures are all nice to haves. The price isn't bad at $30, and it actually is a far better deal than the old one, and it looks much better.

At the same time though, it's probably the weakest of the Episode II sets (Duel on Geonosis is just a bad set but has good parts). It's a decent model, but if I compare it with things like the Corporate Alliance Tank Droid, it comes up short while being more expensive. It's not as useful parted out as Duel, given that most of the parts are technic elements. I think the real difference for this set will be a good sale, maybe down into the $25 or less range. Or maybe just the need for more female jedi.

What I liked

  • Yet Another New Jedi is always welcome

  • A revised set that improves the look and piece count, but keeps the same price? What is this, opposite day?

  • The big droid looks so much better than the previous version


What I didn't like

  • Set is awkward and the legs are very wobbly, even though they're well built and the set isn't as fragile as before

  • Poor Super Battle Droids still don't get a back... just those mold lines

  • Parts value isn't as good as the other sets from this wave


You can pick up the 75016 Spider Homing Droid on Amazon.com right now
---
Permalink: http://www.fbtb.net/2013/10/25/review-75016-homing-spider-droid/
Staff
 
Posts: 1
Joined: Fri Feb 13, 2009 8:19 pm

Re: Review: 75016 Homing Spider Droid

Postby Ultron32 » Fri Oct 25, 2013 1:24 pm

I was never able to figure out why they got rid of the blaster arms.
Thought you'd like this about the Vatican cameos.
Ultron32
 
Posts: 456
Joined: Fri Aug 31, 2012 10:47 am

Re: Review: 75016 Homing Spider Droid

Postby dWhisper » Fri Oct 25, 2013 1:50 pm

Less "get rid of," much more "why were they only available in a couple of sets"
If the above post didn't offend you, you're probably reading it wrong.
dWhisper
 
Posts: 24
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2009 10:56 pm
Location: The Arkansas Wasteland

Re: Review: 75016 Homing Spider Droid

Postby Trooper10 » Fri Oct 25, 2013 6:44 pm

I just hate those 'super' battle droids - every single one I've ever got has had the leg clip break and about 50% of arms have broken and I don't even play with 'em. I mean if you just look at them funny, they snap off...I can deal with occasional regular droid arms breaking especially since you usually get spares but these things are junk and so, detract from any set they are in for me. :'(
Trooper10
 
Posts: 180
Joined: Sun Mar 20, 2011 2:58 am

Re: Review: 75016 Homing Spider Droid

Postby murphquake » Sat Oct 26, 2013 12:06 am

i keep hearing that SBD arms and legs break but all of mine are just fine... I do have a solution for the HSD's legs. TLG, for reasons unbeknown to me, used light bley technic pins to hold the legs to the struts and the struts to the body... the problem is that grey pins are frictionless pins, used for free spinning wheels and such. I swapped them for black pins, which have friction and it completely solves the sloppy leg problem of the HSD. I changed all 16, but probably only need to do 8 if you're stingy or somehow short on one of the most common lego pieces ever, the ever popular black technic pin.
Standing up perfectly straight:
Image
FIX Your Homing Spider Droid in 16 Easy Steps by murphquake, on Flickr

New friend's animals in no danger even on only 3 legs:
Image
FIX Your Homing Spider Droid in 16 Easy Steps by murphquake, on Flickr
murphquake
 
Posts: 171
Joined: Thu Feb 23, 2012 2:49 pm
Location: NYC

Re: Review: 75016 Homing Spider Droid

Postby dWhisper » Sat Oct 26, 2013 4:50 am

I've broken more than a few SBD clips, but LEGO has always replaced them when I've asked. Usually they tend to break when they're in storage and something came loose, or I'm fiddling. The big problem is just the nature of that particular plastic, which is very brittle compared to other parts.

I actually messed with that pin solution murph mentioned (since he brought it up in chat yesterday morning). I found that you could get a nice general effect just replacing the outer pins with the friction pins, and leaving the inner one as the no friction pins. Makes it far easier to pose.
If the above post didn't offend you, you're probably reading it wrong.
dWhisper
 
Posts: 24
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2009 10:56 pm
Location: The Arkansas Wasteland

Re: Review: 75016 Homing Spider Droid

Postby Trooper10 » Sat Oct 26, 2013 8:21 am

Do they still replace the original blueish metallic ones? All of these have broken legs for me. I actually found a couple of newer gunmetal colored ones that haven't snapped yet, but I do tend to just keep them in storage...I just can't imagine how they stand up to kiddie play wear...
Trooper10
 
Posts: 180
Joined: Sun Mar 20, 2011 2:58 am

Re: Review: 75016 Homing Spider Droid

Postby dWhisper » Sat Oct 26, 2013 1:56 pm

Doubt they still have the pieces to replace the original ones, but I've gotten replacement gunmetal ones a few times
If the above post didn't offend you, you're probably reading it wrong.
dWhisper
 
Posts: 24
Joined: Fri Jan 16, 2009 10:56 pm
Location: The Arkansas Wasteland


Return to Reviews

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 2 guests